Texas fourth-grader suspended for having an imagination and book

Kermit Elementary School fourth-grader Aiden Steward was suspended recently after he brought a ring to school and pretended it was the “one ring to rule them all” from J.R.R. Tolkien’s legendary Middle Earth.

I wish this news was as fictional as the fantasy universe Tolkien created.

Unfortunately, it isn’t.

The Odessa American, a newspaper based in Odessa, Texas, broke the news Friday. The American sums up the incident as follows:

His father, Jason Steward, said the family had been to see “The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies” last weekend. His son brought a ring to his class at Kermit Elementary School and told another boy his magic ring could make the boy disappear.

Steward said the principal said threats to another child’s safety would not be tolerated – whether magical or not. Principal Roxane Greer declined to comment on the matter.

The New York Daily News (as well as multiple national and international news outlets) picked up the story soon after.

The Daily News reports this is Aiden’s third suspension since enrolling at Kermit Elementary School in August 2014. (The first two suspensions were in-school suspensions.)

The first suspension was doled out to Aiden because he referred to a student as black. The second suspension, his father said, occurred when Aiden’s class was studying the solar system. The 9-year-old took his favorite book, “The Big Book of Knowledge,” to school in an effort to impress his teacher.

Instead, he received another suspension because — brace yourselves — the book contained a segment about pregnancy and contained an illustration of a pregnant woman.

Since when is explaining pregnancy lewd or offensive? “The Big Book of Knowledge” does not go into age-inappropriate detail of human reproduction.

Any person who is not outraged over this must not have a pulse.

A child was punished for possessing a book. A child was punished for having an imagination. These are not acts of terrorism or delinquency. These are the acts of a child who wants to learn. These are the acts of a child with unplugged imagination.

These are the traits we, as adults and as a society, must foster. We must never suppress the joy of imagination and learning. It is from these two elements that all innovation and art springs.

Love of learning and use of imagination are among the very assets that define our humanity.

For a school — a school, of all places — to mute and punish a child for having a book and an imagination is a blood-boiling, teeth-grinding outrage.

The journalist in me wants to withhold judgment. I only have one side of the story; without a statement from the school, I have only half the facts.

The basic human being in me wants to move into that school district, knock on every school board member’s door, and demand the principal and teacher be handed pink slips. No child should be shamed or punished for exercising imagination. No child deserves to be punished for possessing an encyclopedia.

This case is an embarrassment to Kermit Elementary School and public education.


UPDATE: The Kermit Independent School District released a statement to the Odessa American in a news release Monday. The statement says, in part:

Kermit ISD cannot disclose information on the discipline of any KISD student because it is confidential under the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA). We would, however, like to emphasize that our teachers and administrators are well trained and have properly implemented the district’s policy and student code of conduct, and certainly do not base disciplinary placement decisions on literary or cinematic references as reported by the Odessa American.

Kermit ISD strives to keep all students safe, and to focus above all on providing them with the highest quality of education. There are many good things going on in Kermit ISD that deserve far more attention than this matter, and for that reason, the district will provide no further comment.

The highest quality of education, eh?

Kermit’s high-quality education must not include imagination or a thirst for knowledge.

Yes, Kermit, the many good things in your district deserve attention as well, but the good does not mean we should ignore the bad.

It means the bad should be discussed and rectified so our full attention can shift back to the good.


Want to voice your thoughts or concerns to the administration of Kermit Independent School District and/or the surrounding community? Here’s who to contact:

  • Superintendent Bill Boyd, 601 S. Poplar, Kermit, TX 79745; 432-586-1000;
    bboyd@kisd.esc18.net
  • Principal Roxane Greer, 601 S, Poplar, Kermit, TX 79745; 432-586-1030; rgreer@kisd.esc18.net
  • Submit a letter to the editor to the Odessa American. An online form can be filled out here.
This entry was posted in Unplugged imagination and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Texas fourth-grader suspended for having an imagination and book

  1. trinitygrau says:

    This was a very interesting post. I think that the school has a good point on the first two offenses. Let me explain before you pop a vein: for some adults (parents, I mean) it’s not ok to show a second-grader a picture of/ and or information about pregnancy. So while I respect that the kid wanted just to learn, the school has an advantage in this respect. On the other hand, it’s just plain wrong if he wasn’t pointing out this information. What kind of person gives a kid suspension for something he wasn’t even doing? And the last I think was wrong. If he was just kidding around and using his imagination, then he shouldn’t be punished.

    This is just my opinion, but that’s how I see it.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I can’t comment on the first in-school suspension because not enough context was provided in news reports. Depending on the manner in which Aiden Steward commented on a classmate’s skin color, it may or may not have been inappropriate, and may or may not have merited a suspension. But I believe the second and third suspensions were unmerited.

      I respect a teacher’s duty to filter inappropriate content out of the classroom, but in the case of Aiden bringing “The Big Book of Knowledge” to school, I think the punishment was too extreme for the infraction. Rather than a suspension, I believe confiscating the book for the school day and explaining to Aiden why it wasn’t allowed in the classroom would be more appropriate. Then, at the end of the day, the book could be returned and he could be told to take it home with the instructions not to bring it back to school.

      Additionally, rather than suspending Aiden, I think the teacher could have sent a note to the parents explaining why the book isn’t allowed in school. DK, the publisher of “The Big Book of Knowledge,” lists the book for ages 8 to 12. The parents may have believed it was fine for their son to bring the book to school, only to learn it ended in suspension. If parents know the classroom expectations, they can help by explaining to Aiden what books and belongings can be taken to school and which are for home only. Open lines of communication go a long way toward resolving problems.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s